We have built stores on both platforms for a decade, and we still run some of each. The honest answer to "which one" depends less on features than on who is going to look after the store at 11pm when something breaks. Here is how we advise founders.
Shopify, in one paragraph
You rent a store that works. Hosting, checkout, payments, security and most of the fiddly parts are handled for you, and the admin is pleasant. The trade is control and cost: you pay a monthly fee plus app fees plus, unless you use Shopify Payments, a transaction fee, and some things you want to customise are either an app or impossible. For a founder who wants to sell and not run servers, that trade is usually right.
WooCommerce, in one paragraph
You own a store built on WordPress. The software is free; everything around it is not. You pay for hosting, you choose and update plugins, you are responsible when an update breaks the checkout, and you can change absolutely anything. For a store with unusual products, complex pricing, a content-heavy site, or a team that already lives in WordPress, that control is worth a lot. For a founder with nobody technical on hand, it is a second job.
The costs people forget
| Shopify | WooCommerce | |
|---|---|---|
| Platform fee | Monthly plan | None |
| Hosting | Included | £20 to £200 a month, more for busy stores |
| Apps and plugins | Many are monthly subscriptions | Many are yearly licences |
| Transaction fees | Extra unless you use Shopify Payments | Payment provider's fee only |
| Someone to keep it running | Mostly not needed | Needed. Updates, backups, security, speed |
| A broken checkout at 11pm | Shopify's problem | Your problem |
The last two rows are the real decision. A WooCommerce store without someone maintaining it drifts: plugins fall behind, the site slows down, and one day a WordPress update and a payment plugin disagree. A Shopify store without maintenance mostly keeps working.
What we tell founders
- Physical products, standard pricing, small team, no developer: Shopify. Spend the time you save on products and marketing.
- Complex products or pricing, B2B rules, a content site attached, or a developer on the team: WooCommerce can be the better tool, and it is cheaper at volume once you have the maintenance covered.
- Already on one and it works: stay. Migrations cost more than the monthly difference for years, and you lose SEO and history in the move unless it is done carefully.
- Selling on Amazon as well: either, but plan for stock and pricing to be managed across both from day one, not bolted on later.
The thing neither platform does
Neither one tells you what to do. Both show orders, both show a gross margin that overstates your profit, and neither sees your ad spend, your supplier dates or your WhatsApp. Whichever you choose, the work of joining those together, so you know which ad to kill and what to order today, is still yours. That is the part we built PixL for, and it reads both platforms the same way, so the choice above is about the store, not about us.
If you want a second opinion on your specific situation, ask us. We will tell you which one we would pick for your store, including when the answer is "stay where you are".
